fbpx Stick or twist? | Progress In Mind

Stick or twist?

Following a stormy night in Amsterdam, we travelled through the (thankfully short-lived) rain to attend the appropriately named brainstorming session. This was designed to address a question that has been around for many years, but has little research evidence attached to it: When should antipsychotic drugs be switched in partial responders or non-responders in the acute treatment of schizophrenia?

The chair of this session, Dr Michael Davidson from Israel, was joined by Dr Stephan Heres and Stefan Leucht, both from Germany, to introduce and discuss this subject. Dr Davidson frequently returned to the statement that in psychiatry we often do things that make sense but don’t necessarily turn out to be true (supported by the evidence), so it was refreshing to hear some of the evidence base supporting a response to this question.

In the past, it was thought that there is a delay in the onset of activity of antipsychotic drugs of a few weeks. It is now known, however, that this is not the case.

How long must I wait?

In the past, it was thought that there is a delay in the onset of activity of antipsychotic drugs of a few weeks. It is now known, however, that this is not the case. Improvements in positive symptoms are seen almost immediately after starting treatment, indeed much of the beneficial effect is apparent within 2 weeks. Building on this information, several studies have demonstrated that a less than 20% reduction in the total score on the PANSS or BPRS after 2 weeks’ treatment predicts non-response (less than 50% reduction in total score) at 6 weeks. This 20% reduction in BPRS or PANSS equates to ‘minimally better’ on the CGI. Thus, those patients who are not minimally better after a 2-week trial of an antipsychotic are unlikely to respond if that regimen is continued unchanged. One possible strategy for these patients is for them to immediately switch to another therapy.

A change is as good as a rest?

Studies of switching need to be carefully designed, to account for factors such as possible differences in efficacy of the comparator therapies, the need to titrate to the same doses of each antipsychotic under the different switching conditions, and the question of whether to switch to a similar or very different compound. The so-called SWITCH study, involving two antipsychotics, randomised patients who failed to respond after 2 weeks to either continue receiving their original therapy or to switch to the alternate antipsychotic under double-blind conditions. The results demonstrated that with early switching after 2 weeks, patients who failed to respond to their first antipsychotic had almost as good outcomes after switching therapy as those who responded to their initial therapy and therefore had no need to switch. This finding was not dependent on which antipsychotic the patients received first or switched to, only on the process of switching itself.

The implications of this study, if extended to other antipsychotics, was discussed within the session. In the clinic, these results would suggest, a 2-week trial of a particular antipsychotic should give a good indication of whether the patient will respond to that treatment. If they do not, then switching earlier rather than later may give them a good chance of experiencing beneficial effects within a relatively short time scale.  

Our correspondent’s highlights from the symposium are meant as a fair representation of the scientific content presented. The views and opinions expressed on this page do not necessarily reflect those of Otsuka and Lundbeck.
Country selection
We are registering that you are located in Brazil - if that's correct then please continue to Progress in Mind Brazil
You are leaving Progress in Mind
Le informazioni contenute nel nuovo sito prescelto possono non essere conformi al D.Ivo 219/06 che regola la pubblicità dei medicinali per uso umano e le opinioni espresse non riflettono necessariamente le posizioni dell’azienda, non sono da essa avvallate.
Accesso riservato a Operatori Sanitari
Per accedere si prega di registrarsi o, in caso sia già stato fatto, di autenticarsi
L’accesso a Progress in Mind Italia è consentito unicamente agli Operatori Sanitari (medici e farmacisti). I contenuti di questo sito sono prodotti da un team di Operatori Sanitari il cui obiettivo è presentare le ultime novità in ambito psichiatrico e neurologico, attraverso interviste, registrazioni audio/video di seminari con opinion leader, report e sintesi di congressi sia internazionali che nazionali. Per poter accedere al sito è quindi necessario registrarsi e fornire alcuni dati così da poter verificare che l‘utente sia un Operatore Sanitario.
Please confirm your email
We have just sent you an email, with a confirmation link.
Before you can gain full access - you need to confirm your email.
The information on this site is exclusively intented for health care professionals.
All the information included in the Website is related to products of the local market and, therefore, directed to health professionals legally authorized to prescribe or dispense medications with professional practice. The technical information of the drugs is provided merely informative, being the responsibility of the professionals authorized to prescribe drugs and decide, in each concrete case, the most appropriate treatment to the needs of the patient.
Register for access to Progress in Mind in your country